A masterpiece of post-rock.
Shortly after Christmas 2001, I was wandering around the Tower Records1 in Schaumburg, Illinois looking for CDs2 to buy. Shopping for new music was one of my favorite things to do, and stopping in at this particular Tower was an absolute must anytime I was nearby.3 As I was digging through the racks, the sound of an organ interspersed with what sounded like a sonar ping grabbed my attention. A few moments later I’m hearing one of my favorite sounds: a noisy, melodic guitar. Then some of the most ethereal vocals I’d ever heard kicked in. At this point I’m hooked and need to know what’s playing, so I ran4 to the front of the store to see what album was responsible for these amazing sounds. I don’t remember what else I bought that day,5 but I know I bought Ágætis Byrjun. And thus began the start of a multi-decade love for Sigur Rós, and this album especially.
Listening Notes and Track Breakdown
Unlike most of our reviews, I won’t be discussing the lyrics for this album. There are two very good reasons for that:
- Most of the lyrics are sung in Icelandic, and I don’t speak Icelandic.
- The lyrics in Olsen olsen and at the end of Ágætis Byrjun are sung in Vonlenska,6 which isn’t really a language and is more akin to jazz scat singing.
In lieu of talking about lyrics, I’m going to talk about the instrumentation of the songs.7 The band did a lot of experimentation with this album, both with the instruments they played and the methods they used in the studio. You’ve probably heard most of that experimentation on other records at this point, but there’s one bit of experimentation that I think remains unique to Sigur Rós: Jónsi’s guitar. Throughout this album you might find yourself wondering how they got the guitar sound, the answer is that it’s being played with a cello bow instead of being strummed or picked. It creates a really unique sound that I don’t think I’ve ever heard any other band recreate.
Listening to this record again ahead of and while writing this, a few things come to mind:
- After 25 years of this record (and many others in the genre that have come after it), it’s hard to convey just how different it was to anything else at the time.8
- Even after living with this record for as long as I have, I still enjoy it and hear something new on each listen.
- When I bought this record in 2001, I had no idea it was going to be an entry point to so many other bands over the years.9
With all that in mind, let’s get into the songs.
Intro
Just barely more than a minute-and-a-half, but a perfect introduction to let you know that you aren’t sitting down to listen to a normal rock record. The first minute is made up of pieces of a later track that have been reversed. Following that is a bit of ambient background noise and that sonar ping sound I mentioned earlier which will feature prominently in the second track on the album.
Svefn-g-englar
This was the song that grabbed my attention in Tower records all those years ago. It starts with the briefest snippet of a reversed vocal track, and very quickly settles into a slow, contemplative groove. Compared to some of the other songs on the album, it’s a relatively simple instrumentation: an organ, bass, drums, guitar, and that sonar ping sound. At the 2:00 minute mark Jónsi’s vocals come into the mix. The almost whispered falsetto adds an ethereal vibe to the song, and still to this day makes me realize I’m listening to something special. Around six minutes in we get a little mini-crescendo before the band settles back into their groove. You’ll hear this formula of alternating between quiet and loud repeat throughout the album to great effect.
The main groove fades out with some augmented vocals with nearly a minute left on the track. Then we get a snippet of what sounds like it could be radio static overlaid with a drumbeat that starts out sounding like a heartbeat and then devolves into arrhythmia.
Starálfur
If you’re a Wes Anderson fan, you’ve probably heard this song since he used it for the climax of The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou. It’s moment full of complexity and conflicting emotions for the lead character, and the song fits every emotional beat of the scene so well you’d assume it had been written for it. It’s a beautiful way to wrap up a beautiful movie about how messy and complicated life can be.10 If you haven’t seen the film skip this clip and go watch it in its entirety. Otherwise, here’s a clip:
My favorite part of this song is probably the transition that happens around three minutes into the song. It’s another one of those mini-crescendo’s, this time going from a swell of strings into a section of just vocals over a simple strummed guitar line. And just when you think that might be the end the full band (strings and all) come bursting back in. Perfection.
Flugufrelsarinn
The organ! It wasn’t until I saw the band live, a few years after I bought this record, that I realized why this organ sounded so good. The secret11 is that it’s a harmonium, a type of organ that uses a bellows to pass air over reeds. And in this case, it’s a harmonium that involves manually inflating those bellows with a foot pump. I don’t think I’d ever seen anyone play an instrument like this before then, and it’s still fascinating to watch.
Like Svefn-g-englar, this is another song made up of a contemplative groove but instead of being interspersed with mini-crescendos we get more experimentation with layers of sound to create the quiet-loud-quiet effect.12 The song always gives me a feeling of someone reminiscing or feeling nostalgic, even without understanding the lyrics.13
Ný batterí
If you aren’t paying close attention, it’s difficult to tell when Flugufrelsarinn ends and Ný batterí begins. The former fades almost perfectly into the beginning of the latter with a sparse bit of brass over some ambient sound.14 For the first half of the song, the bass line drives everything else happening. But a little after the halfway mark that changes when the drums come in amplifying the frenetic energy of the song. There are a couple caesurae in the latter half of the song, with the band coming back stronger after each. You’ll likely be disappointed when the song ends, but the good news is you can skip back and listen to it again.
Hjartað hamast (bamm bamm bamm)
The band has said that they’ve never been happy with this song. 15 While I might agree that there are parts that don’t work (the harmonica always feels really out of place), as a whole, I think the song fits nicely into it’s place on the album. It’s a great example of how the band can layer a bunch of different sounds and textures to create something more beautiful than any one part would be on its own.
Viðrar vel til loftárása
If I had to choose one song to epitomize this entire album (and perhaps the entire band), this would probably be it. It’s a great example of the band starting with a relatively simple instrumentation (just a piano followed by the bass) and slowly layering more on to build to multiple mini-crescendos. The peaks aren’t as high as some of their other songs, but the way they’re used is perfect. The final movement of the song ends with what sounds like a symphony descending into pure chaos, 16 all barely held together by the drums. It’s a strangely cathartic way to end a song.
Olsen olsen
Based solely on the slower tempo of this song, you might not believe this next statement. This song is pure joy. From the brightness of the piano melody, to the lilting flute, to the choir at the crescendo. If you aren’t smiling by the end of this one, you have a cold dead heart. I’m including the version of this song that appears in the band’s 2007 film Heima because it’s a great live rendition of the song (though sadly missing the choir), and a fantastic chance for you to see Jónsi playing guitar with a cello bow.
Ágætis byrjun
This album is widely considered to be one of the most well-known examples of the genre post-rock, but if you were to only listen to this song you might not understand why. Compared to the rest of the album, this is a pretty straightforward song. The instrumentation is largely acoustic guitar, bass, drums, and piano, all wrapped up into a normal ballad structure. There is a little bit of texture layered in later in the song (mostly through backing vocals). If you wanted to sneakily introduce someone to post-rock, this might be the song to use.
Avalon
This song works as a refrain for the entire album. It starts with what sounds like someone quickly slowing down the playback of a tape. And it turns out that might actually be what we’re hearing since this song is quite literally the end of Starálfur slowed considerably. For me, it’s a great way to end the record and reflect on everything I’ve just listened to.
- R.I.P. ↩
- This would have been about two years before my first iPod, and close to ten years before I would start buying vinyl ↩
- Which sadly wasn’t as frequently as I’d like since I live in D.C. at the time ↩
- Not literally, that would be ridiculous. ↩
- It was never just one CD. ↩
- More about Vonlenska. ↩
- Full disclosure, I’m not entirely qualified for that. I took piano lessons for a couple years as a kid, and played guitar through high school and college. Beyond that I’ve just been a listener for my entire life. ↩
- At least for me. ↩
- The list is long and may show up in future reviews, but I can confidently say that I wouldn’t have been ready for Godspeed You! Black Emperor without first hearing this record. ↩
- At least that’s my take, I’m probably less qualified to critique film than music… ↩
- Probably not a secret if you’re more familiar with the world of organs than me. ↩
- I told you that would be a recurring theme. ↩
- According to the band’s own write-up, this song is about one of the band members remembering their childhood, so I guess feelings can transcend language. ↩
- It’s Jónsi’s bowed guitar again! ↩
- See their notes here. ↩
- Chaos in the best possible way. ↩