This month’s selection is a partnership with the Head In Oven Record Club.
The Head in Oven Record Club puts a lot of thought into which records appropriately represent what this service intends to bring to its customer.1 As such, we want our selections to:
- Be a personal all-time favorite record
- By a personal all-time favorite band
- Be a versatile, go-to record in our personal collection
- Be an album that has a meaningful place in our life
- Not be a 21 Pilots album.
We here at the Head in Oven Record Club lied to your unsuspecting face in our description of our previous club selection, HORC1, and we’re not even a little sorry about it.
Yes, we did “put a lot of thought into which record - the first in this series - would appropriately represent what this service intends to bring to its customer” with HORC1. However, the record that we had intended to select as HORC1 was, at the time, out of print. Not only was it out of print, but it was also confirmed by the band that no additional copies would be printed owing to legal issues with the ownership rights of the record. Unexpectedly, you’ve just received your copy of what was intended to be the actual HORC1.2 Like it or not,3 you’re about to find out how that came to happen.
How we got a brand new copy of this “out of print” record
Evan Weiss, technically, is Into It. Over It (IIOI). He’s the principal songwriter, singer, and guitarist. He has had a rolling cast of players roll through and play on and tour each record and, until recently, has been the only permanent member of the band. Initially, IIOI put out their releases on small labels and distributed them through the usual channels. That all began to change when one of those small labels, No Sleep Records4 , failed to pay Evan royalties for 3 IIOI releases5 while they had a 4th unreleased full length album, Proper6 , also in their possession. No Sleep Records would go on to release Proper (digital and vinyl) as scheduled, but only began paying royalties on it after Evan filed a lawsuit7 . Evan would eventually exit his contract with No Sleep Records after turning in a song called “Contractual Obligation” to fulfill the last of his, um, contractual obligations with them.
From then on, Evan became a DIY-guy. He started his own label, Storm Chasers LTD8 , began funding the release of his own records, pressing and distributing them himself, and putting out records for other bands in his orbit9 . To help fund the label and its releases, Evan became an early adopter of Patreon. We’ll spare the full rundown of the Patreon subscriber benefits and tiers10 , but a little context here helps fill in some details of how this particular pressing of Proper came to be in your possession.
All of Evan’s Patreon subscribers are granted access to a private Discord channel11 , inclusive of updates directly from the man himself. One of Evan’s updates12 confirmed that he wouldn’t be pressing any additional copies of Proper (No Sleep owned the rights) and that he didn’t have any copies of his own to sell (No Sleep was the sole distributor and it was believed to be sold out). He also disclosed the details about the royalties and the lawsuit that were mentioned above in the same post.
A few months after Evan declared Proper’s vinyl life dead, No Sleep Records had to close its doors13
. During that process, they began liquidating their warehouse, including
previously-not-known-to-exist vinyl copies of Proper, at a massive discount. We stumbled on No Sleep’s fire sale during our routine scouring of their site, in hopes that a copy would appear for inclusion as a future HORC release. Not knowing any of the backstory above, that sale is where we obtained your copy14
of the record.
We here at Head in Oven Record Club like happy endings15 and, thankfully, the story doesn’t end here. Evan heard word of No Sleep’s demise16 , bought all of the remaining copies of Proper back from them at cost, and then sold the remaining copies via his own site. What you’re holding in your hands isn’t quite the indie rock version of Chinese Democracy17 or Extraordinary Machine18 , but it has its similarities.
You’re definitely asking yourself: what could possibly compel anyone to care about any of this? What inspiring cause would motivate someone to go through the trouble of writing all of this down despite knowing that anyone19 who reads it will likely forget nearly everything that they read and that those readers20 21 won’t get even a single second of the precious time that they spent reading this story returned to them? We here at the Head in Oven Record Club, obviously, are not even a little sorry about that, either22 .
We are not going to argue about superior vinyl sound quality or that you need a high end audio system to listen to vinyl. We will argue, though, that there is no experience akin to opening up a physical copy of an album, digging through the liner notes, reading along with the lyrics, and being fully immersed in what you’re experiencing.
This specific copy of Proper nearly died in some greedy shyster’s warehouse, robbing an independent artist of the few bucks that it would’ve put in his pocket. You’re holding Evan’s victory in that battle in your hands and you get to partake in the joy of experiencing what has been pressed into its grooves23 knowing that both Evan and24 I thought it was worth the fight for you to own this record25 .
What this album means to the Head in Oven Record Club
We26 first encountered Into It. Over It. on March 1, 2014 at the Bottom Lounge in Chicago. As usual, we were there to see the second band on the bill27 , The World Is a Beautiful Place and I’m No Longer Afraid to Die (TWIABP). TWIABP was at the forefront of the fourth-wave emo revival. They were aping bands like American Football, Dismemberment Plan, Cap’n Jazz, etc.,28 righting the wrongs of “mall emo”, and bringing the genre back from a 15 year slumber. It cannot be overstated 1) how happy we were to hear this kind of music live once again and 2) how excited we were to see TWIABP29 . We were shocked and floored by 1) the existence of Into It. Over It’s genre-spanning and crossover sound and 2) the magnitude and quality of their live show30 . Since then, we’ve been immersed in Evan’s entire catalog which includes not only Into It. Over It, but also features Evan in several other bands31 , all of whose records are now released on Storm Chasers, LTD.
Over time, we’ve come to appreciate Evan’s adoption of Chicago as his hometown32 , his contributions to the sound of the Chicago indie scene, and his all-around good guy vibes. He was on deck to play at our wedding33 , but touring put a stop to that. He’s always available at the merch table at his shows, remembers who folks are34 , and goes out of his way to foster a community of inclusion. For us here at Head in the Oven record club, he’s a Chicago music icon and stalwart that, sadly, too few appreciate.
Sonically, this record synthesizes alternative rock, math rock, twinkle emo, and punk. Somehow, all of this stuff makes sense together, even when it is all smashed into a single song. The bass guitar on this record often sounds like a standard, 6 string guitar and can be very hard to discern in the mix at times. After seeing several live gigs and many iterations of Evan’s bands, in some of which he plays bass, we noticed that he uses the same amp/head35 combo regardless of whether he is playing bass or guitar36 . The low end of his records and his live shows is MASSIVE.
Lyrically, Proper predominantly covers two topics: failed relationships and the music business. The relationship-focused lyrics have a way of pulling you back into the minutiae of some of the toughest moments of your past. The focus is rarely the breakup itself or the specific events that contributed to it. Instead, the details recall the mundane path of getting to those big moments, discovering the truth that you’d been avoiding, or the emotions that lead the charge forward after the end. The business-related songs call out scenesters, critics, and labels for a litany of offenses37 .
Lyrically and sonically, Evan claims that this record does not contain a single song with a chorus. We have listened to this record hundreds of times and, finally, think that we’ve sorted out what he means. Some songs on Proper contain a repeated melody (aka a chorus) but use different lyrics when the melody is repeated. He does not count those identical melodies with slightly modified lyrics as choruses, which is a technicality if you ask us. Other songs do genuinely lack a chorus altogether.
Surprisingly, owing to how great these sometimes very oddly-structured songs are, you will 1) forget to track whether the songs actually have a chorus and 2) fail to notice the novel structure of these songs altogether. A few of these songs change into and out of uncommon time signatures and all of them leverage the same non-standard38 guitar tuning. You likely won’t notice those elements, either.
What you will notice is that these songs sound great and that they will make you feel the same raw emotions, no matter how many times you hear them. Lastly, you’ll likely notice a thematic carryover from HORC1: this album has a respectable number of songs with choirs of
whoa-ohs39
.
This record is best consumed with the lyrics sheet in-hand and a glass of your finest thinking-bourbon in the other.
Listening Notes and Track Breakdown (With chorus/no-chorus analysis.)
Embracing Facts (No Chorus)
The album opener assertively rips off the band-aid that has been carefully placed on self-inflicted wounds earned by prolonging the inevitable.
How the hell could I have been so dumb?
As an outspoken man with a well-sharpened tongue I sort of thought I'd start to change with age
But I've just stayed the same
…
I'll scream at the wall as you sing the blues
The minor chords that you and I simply can't afford
The song starts loud and, somehow, gets louder after the first verse. The change in volume occurs when the distortion kicks in on the aforementioned Sovtek gear. You may also notice a signature of Evan’s sound here: during these volume swells, he often kicks the bass up a notch in the mix or adds some extra distortion and has the bass guitar follow on beat with the kick drum. It sounds huge every single time.
Discretion & Depressing People (Repeated melody, different lyrics)
We’re not sure whether this song is directed at an industry person or someone else, but you can certainly point the lyrics at just about any asshole out there.
Your lack of confidence is not a right to verbally abuse
I should've said this to your face
But what's the use?
It's the awful ones like you that keep the better people sane
So we could all be better off if you're the same
This is the first song on the record to feature some layered whoa-ohs, one of our favorite melodic choices here at Head in the Oven Record Club.
Fortunate Friends (Repeated lyrics + melody = Chorus. BUSTED, EVAN)
This one seems to be about a music writer or annoying hipster and, strangely, seems to have a repeated chorus (both lyrics and melody, no modifications). We love the first line.
Saw you leaving early when you showed up late
…
I'd like to walk around inside your shoes
Between your sewing circle and the truth
Passing credentials through a status you've assumed
This song also features the kick drum/bass/in sync trick that we mentioned above. It starts just before the “crusade of being fake” lyric in the middle of the song, kicking things up a couple of notches. Feel free to headbang.
No Good Before Noon (One repeated lyrical phrase. No Chorus.)
This track opens with a single electric guitar and leaves out the drums for the entirety. It is a nice, deliberate change of pace that offers a break from the 3 scorchers that come before it.
I admit that I have realized
I'm not built for nine to fives40
But you know I'm no good before noon
Write it Right (Repeated melody, one single word changed.)
Force fed the static
Dressed head to toe in black
Could you repeat this?
Do you honestly believe this?
The definition's dead
So print to nonfiction
A fluid guide to better diction
There is no doubt in our mind that this song is written about a Pitchfork reviewer or an amalgamation of them. The “guide to better diction” line is impeccable and is a dead giveaway. The guitar work during the bridge of this song (following the “I guess it's confusing/Trying to keep score41 /When you can't tell who is winning”) is absolutely bonkers. The precision of the picking pattern, palm muting, and the melody/fretwork are all things of beauty on their own. We don’t know how he does all of them together simultaneously. That brief phrase of guitar playing is a hallmark of Evan’s playing style and one of our favorite guitar movements ever put to tape.
Midnight: Carroll Street (Repeated melody, different lyrics.)
We here at HORC are always on board with a great breakup song. We are also hard-pressed to think of many better than this one. The description of the moratorium detective work, piecing things together, trying to make it all make sense is perfect.
I'm demanding some answers
I'm keeping up with double standards
I am between the words you're telling me
With a fine toothed comb
I'm drawing lines in my hindsight
Until the stories start to line up right
These details bent and broke us down
Hearing this song live immediately activates our tear ducts every single time42 . The massive build at the end of the song follows directly along with the emotional release of the story. We could write volumes about this song. We won’t. We do, however, ask that you process this one and let it linger for a while.
Connecticut Steps (Repeated melody, different lyrics—one changed word.)
This song captures Evan’s reaction to hearing the news that a friend of his, Mitch Dubey, was murdered in a home invasion in Connecticut. There was no good transition into that headline. We attempted to come up with something and gave up43 .
On a morning in Baton Rouge
I change position to some heartbreaking news
I remember the sobs in the call about you
And I'm detuned
To what rests on Connecticut steps
Evidently, the suspect forced his way into the apartment, sat its inhabitants on a couch at gunpoint, and asked them to empty their pockets. They complied. Mitch’s last words, supposedly, were “Dude, put down the gun.” After speaking those words, he was shot in the chest.
The next chapter of this story comes on the album that follows Proper, Intersections. The song,
A Shaking of Leaves44
, recalls Evan’s reaction to hearing that the suspect had been caught.
The New Haven expose
Confirmed they caught a killer
Well I caught a chill
When the newsprint said the gunman was nineteen
You can Google all of this on your own, but the summary is that the lead witness in the case was erratic and the suspect was declared innocent in a jury trial. A Shaking of Leaves is an incredibly moving song played live, enhanced when you know the backstory.
Staring At The Ceiling (No chorus)
This song is self-explanatory, industry missive about someone stealing other people’s songs.
Please forgive me for coming off as rude
I didn't mean to come clean with such an attitude
But it's original sin to sing somebody else's tunes
And try to say they're yours
Musically, this song has another one of our all-time favorite guitar parts. After the “while I sat back” couplet that closes out the vocals, the song is in a standard 4/4 (1-2-3-4) time signature with the guitar, bass, and kick drum playing in sync45 . After 4 of those, the lead guitar peels off and fills in the “and” beats 1-and-2-and-3-and-4-and with what almost sounds like rhythmic feedback. He then flawlessly peels out of that and moves back to playing on beat. It is a simple, clever trick that makes the last 8-16 bars of the song much more interesting.
While you’re here counting along46 to this section, pay attention to all of the drumming that consistently happens on beat 4 and how it almost breaks your count. You don’t typically encounter that much activity in that spot. And now you know a little bit about math rock.
An Evening With Ramsey Beyer (Repeated melody, different lyrics—one changed word.)
We’re not sure about precisely what’s behind the scenes here, but these lyrics are befitting of any good, storied friendship and sounds like an evening that you’d spend with whoever your preferred Ramsey Beyer happens to be.
So I don't have much to offer
Besides an old bike seat and some bad advice
To keeping true with where we'd aged
And translate sarcastic for being nice
Where Your Nights Often End (Repeated melody, different lyrics—one changed word.)
Remember that claim about how well these songs manage to capture the minutiae that surround the big moments? This song slowly unpacks the seemingly boring realization, informed by context clues and harmless details while killing time at a bar, that it’s over. We here at HORC would be lying if we didn’t mention that we have felt this particular couplet for the majority of our lives.
Within the chorus lines of hand-picked songs47
That say that I just don't belong
In the context of the song, it is a beautiful, sad sack way of saying “This sucks and I hate it here.”
You play the part of the thoughtless romantic in
The busy rotation of what goes wrong
But I can't make the lines out
I'll never make the lines out
This also features some awesome, layered, elongated whoa-ohs.
PROPER (Repeated melody, different lyrics—one changed word.)
We here at HORC love a good “turn the page on my self-destruction” song48 . This one is a fantastic representative of that genre and is probably the most uplifting song on Proper. To celebrate something uplifting, here’s some of the pre-page-turn, self-destructive nonsense that we here at HORC love to consume by the gallon.
I'm picking out my poisons from the wall
To the war inside my head
I'd say: I'm getting used to it
I'm getting over it
I'm getting back in bed
The last verse of this song is a passionate, inspired determination to break the cycle49 . Bonus: the last verse is followed by some delightful whoa-ohs that will make you want to listen to the track on repeat..
This is a night worth saving
I will pour my doubts onto the floor
And wear away the pavement
Between my back porch and your door
The Frames That Used To Greet Me (No Chorus)
This song is poetry and our words will only make the experience worse.
- And only occasionally tells them lies of omission ↩
- We have absolutely no regrets for picking Bleed American and stand by every word that we wrote. ↩
- Probably “not” ↩
- See insert included in mailer ↩
- EPs, splits, and singles, not full lengths. ↩
- Into It. Over It’s first proper full length album. Get it? ↩
- They never ended up paying him anything for the other 3 releases ↩
- Named inspired by the movie Twister. Headquartered in Chicago, where he has lived for quite some time ↩
- Also reissues of records that were never released on vinyl or are long out of print, giving the proceeds to those artists ↩
- No we won’t ↩
- Vinyl tier subscribers are given access to an even MORE private channel where Evan shares details about upcoming releases, leaks, vinyl test pressings, and other things you can buy. You also get a record sent to you each month. ↩
- Shared exclusively in the even MORE private channel. We’re members. We’ll wave if you drop by. ↩
- Given the stellar behavior that you’ve come to expect from the royalty-stealing jags at No Sleep Records, this is probably an absolute shocker. ↩
- Heavily discounted, reflecting our overall investment in this enterprise ↩
- Nowhere near as much as Robert Kraft, obviously ↩
- Both earned and deserved ↩
- You know all about this one ↩
- If you don’t know the backstory about the “hostage” version of this Fiona Apple album that was produced by the amazing Jon Brion, it is an interesting rabbit hole to explore ↩
- Also: possibly no one ↩
- Disengaged ↩
- and unfortunate ↩
- Leave us alone, already. ↩
- Primarily sad songs. The joke is on you. Joy is merely a construct. ↩
- most importantly ↩
- One which he recently described as his “least favorite” of his own releases. Clarifying, he said that there are many things he’d do differently now, 13 years after having recorded it. Frankly, that doesn’t surprise us. His studio recordings sound much different—and better—now than they did back then. ↩
- Mike, Janice, Tim Mills, and DT ↩
- Headliners are for posers ↩
- Basically, the Best Friends Forever Fest 2024 lineup ↩
- Who were great that night ↩
- To this day, Evan and co. are a must-see, top 5 live act every single time. ↩
- Pet Symmetry, Their/They’re/There, Couplet, etc. ↩
- By way of NY and PHI ↩
- IIOI opened a two night run of Get Up Kids Shows at the Double Door in 2016. We met him at the merch table, exchanged info, and outlined a plan. The start of his tour for Standards ended up being just a few days before our wedding date. The dream died. We were planning to have him play a song called Anchor. Janice was only made aware of this plan after Evan fell through. ↩
- Most importantly, me ↩
- A Sovtek 100 Watt head is the difference-maker that adds the massive low end that gets even bigger when the distortion pedal gets kicked on. He runs that Sovtek head through an Ampeg half stack cabinet - a staple indie rock amplifier. ↩
- Typically, each instrument features its own specialized gear/amp. The only other band that we’ve noticed doing something similar live was the Black Keys. When they were a two piece, the guitar output was simultaneously split into both a bass rig and a guitar rig. They slapped two microphones -- one pointed at each amp -- in the middle to send out to the house PA. The result was a very full, massive sound coming from a single guitar. Evan doesn’t split his signal and simply uses one rig for everything, but the results sound similar with the Sovtek and the bass. ↩
- Shoutout to No Sleep Records! ↩
- F#/A/C#/F#/A/C# ↩
- Shout out to HORC1 and the abundance of whoa-ohs! The Jimmy Eat World influence is literally everywhere on this record, inclusive of their tragically underrated debut, Static Prevails. ↩
- Evan’s “corporate job” sees him working at Reverb (shout-out, Lakeview!), which is essentially ebay for music gear. He inspects used gear, does product demos, etc. for them. If you watch enough gear demos on their site, you’ll see Evan eventually. ↩
- We’re guessing album review scores here ↩
- Evan plays this song at just about every IIOI live show, so that’s saying something. We’ve seen IIOI more than 10 times, approaching 20. ↩
- Remember, you neither asked for nor pay for this membership. ↩
- Not on this record. Sorry. Do check it out. ↩
- Hey! Its that thing mentioned earlier! Again! ↩
- Or trying to ↩
- In this case, the songs that others would put on, in public, for the sake of camaraderie ↩
- Do not get us started about A Murder of One by Counting Crows. It is maybe the best “turn the page” song and its place as the closing bookend on August and Everything After is perfect. ↩
- Oh no. We got started on A Murder of One by Counting Crows. We here at HORC are equally as enamored that Catapult, the opener on Recovering the Satellites and the very next track in their discography, gets right back to Adam Durtiz’s hopeless, self-defeating, loverlorne, navel-gazing as though the sentiment in A Murder of One was never expressed -- on the heels of massive success, newfound fame, and dating Jennifer Aniston. Art at its finest. ↩