This Old Man is Goin' to Town!
"That is, when I get to heaven
'Cause then I'm gonna get a cocktail, vodka and ginger ale
Yeah I'm gonna smoke a cigarette that's nine miles long"
For my senior year of high school, I went to my Aunt Linda's house in Carlsbad, California for spring break. One of those mornings while deciding what to do, I opened a copy of Rolling Stone (Yes, like a physical magazine) and read an article about 71 year old songwriter John Prine, and his new album The Tree of Forgiveness. He sang about screen doors, heartbreak, and 9 mile long cigarettes so I was immediately interested. This album changed the way I view songwriting, the Midwest, and honestly life in general.
Listening Notes and Track Breakdown
I. Knockin' on Your Screen Door
The album starts off with a happy, upbeat song that'll make you tap your toes. As previously mentioned I was in California when I first heard this, and I won't lie this song made me miss home in Indiana. It feels like a song that would be on the radio when you were a kid, and it's sunny out; The train tracks line especially hits home. The guitar rambles on and starts the album off with some energy. I feel like this song will end up being a folk classic that everybody covers, it's catchy and relatable.
"I can see your back porch, if I close my eyes now
I can hear the train tracks, through the laundry on the line
I'm thinkin' it's your business, but you don't got to answer
I'm knockin' on your screen door, in the summertime"
II. I Have Met My Love Today
This is a good song to fall in love to I bet, textbook JP.
"Doesn't really matter what we had to say
I have met my love today"
I mean what else is there to say, I have met my love today. A simple, but touching Love song.
III. Egg & Daughter Nite, Lincoln Nebraska, 1967 (Crazy Bone)
So this song checks two boxes that I love in songs, long titles and bizarre stories. It's both an old folks home banger and a story of a very niche childhood experience. So the story goes, John Prine was fishing with his buddy John Earl, when Earl told him a story from when he was a kid and lived in Lincoln, Nebraska. On Thursdays the farmers would come to town for the market and their daughters would go to the roller rink, so they called it 'Egg and Daughter Night.' Prine thought the idea was hilarious and later on wrote a song about what he could recall. Prine called Earl up after he wrote the song to fact check it, and it turns out it happened in Norfolk, not Lincoln. But Lincoln1 sounds better so it stayed.
"When the grandkids all are grown, and they put you in a home
And eternity is approaching fast, you're half out of your head
And you probably pissed the bed, and you can't see a thing to save your ass
And far across the prairie (prairie) In the local cemetery ('tery)
They already got your name carved out in stone
When all them nurses say, "Grandpa, why you walk that way?"
Just blame it on that old crazy bone"
IV. Summer's End
I know American Football2 might have a song with a similar name, but this one breaks that one's heart. The sad scholars will study this song for years to come. This song captures that sad feeling of summer ending, and how fleeting those warmer months can feel. It'll make you wanna go home from vacation, and make Spring feel like Fall. The song starts with just the guitar (and maybe a creaky chair?) and slowly builds into a beautifully haunting full band accompaniment. The lyrics hold just as much weight, tugging at your heart strings with a chorus as simple as:
"Come on home
Come on home
No you don't have to be alone
Just come on home"
Fun fact, Fred Again.. sampled/interpolated that hook to this song on 'Come on Home'
V. Caravan of Fools
This song feels like it'd be in a movie. It's dark and mysterious, like a long twisty road. Amazing use of imagery in the lyrics, and the upright bass in this is mixed very well. A powerful song start to finish, I don't have much else to say besides it's just a cool song.
"Love and devotion
Deep as any ocean
Don't play by anybody's rules
With your carousel of horses
And your unforeseen forces
You're running with the caravan of fools"
VI. The Lonesome Friends of Science
Prine, as many of us probably have, contemplated how the world was going to end a time or two. While those questions are out of our grasps, one we still have lingers on... What did Pluto do to not be considered a planet?? That's a load of garbage! It felt nice to find a song that aligned with that sentiment.
Once a mighty planet there
Now just an ordinary star
Hangin' out in Hollywood
In some ol' funky sushi bar"
VII. No Ordinary Blue
This one is for the Saddos3 , a real crier. When I first heard it I liked it, but never thought too much of it; now it may be favorite on the album. It's a song about being sad, plain and simple. It doesn't give too much detail away, but still maintains a genuine conversational quality that feels like you've been there before.
"I hear a lot of empty spaces
I see a big hole in the view
I feel an outline that traces
An imaginary path back to you
This ain't no ordinary blue"
VIII. Boundless Love
This song is a perfect blend of melancholy and hope. A song about yearning for love and eventually being found by the person that you can 'come clean' to. Love is frying pork chops & falling off a jagged cliff at the same time, and this song encapsulates that perfectly.
"Sometimes my old heart is like a washing machine
It bounces around 'til my Soul comes clean
And when I'm clean and hung out to dry
I'm gonna make you laugh until you cry"
IX. God Only Knows
This song is a great bridge into the final track of this album, as it deals with God and the unknown that lies ahead. While I don't get in touch with J-Man4 often, I think this song can mean a multitude of things if you're open to it.
"God only knows the price that you pay
For the ones you hurt along the way
If I should betray myself today
Then God only knows the price I pay"
A song about regret, and how at the end of the day it's only you and God (or whatever) that truly know how you feel. It hits you right in the heart and makes you ponder. I'm willing to bet John Prine could make an atheist cry, which leads into the next song.
X. When I Get to Heaven
Like any good folk song, we're gonna wrap back around to the beginning. 'When I get to Heaven' was the song that Rolling Stone had quoted that originally caught my attention. A man whose idea of heaven is shaking God's hand, checking into a hotel, and starting a band. John Prine had to quit smoking after surviving squamous cell cancer in 1998, and then lung cancer in 2013. His voice was gravely after surgery had removed part of his neck, and for a time was worried he wouldn't be able to sing. This song is extra special with the help of his friends on group vocals, contrasted by spoken parts by Prine in between. The chorus sections sound like a party, and leaves you with such a bittersweet feeling.
After getting to Heaven and getting back into show business, these are the last of his requests:
"And then I'm gonna get a cocktail, vodka and ginger ale
Yeah, I'm gonna smoke a cigarette that's nine miles long
I'm gonna kiss that pretty girl on the tilt-a-whirl
'Cause this old man is goin' to town!"